Hiring the right person is an important process and takes both time and skill. It is the first step in creating mutual success.
I have always subscribed to the theory that you hire for cultural fit over experience. My belief is that with the appropriate knowledge base and skill set, anyone can be taught how to do a particular job. Maybe it is the trainer in me, or the fact that on-the-job training is the way I learned how to perform the duties of my very first job (this is what you do, and this is how you do it). Granted, I was in high school and it was working at a restaurant, but I was doing the very same job as adults who had worked in the restaurant industry for years.
From a hiring perspective, I personally would prefer to spend time teaching a person their job, rather than managing someone’s work performance. Early on in my career, I was assigned to train someone who had no direct experience. However, she had a strong work ethic and wanted to succeed in her role. She asked for feedback on her performance, she watched how other successful representatives made presentations, and took notes. She also spent time practicing her presentation skills and getting comfortable with the material she presented. She did quite well and eventually was able to move on to more senior role in another company.
I was also asked to train my successor, who the company hired to manage a particular group of clients, including several major accounts. She had direct experience and knew what was needed to accomplish the job, but work was not her priority. I knew from the very beginning she was not the right person for the job and not just because our styles of client management were different. I could tell she was not willing to put in the time and effort it took to consistently maintain client satisfaction. Although she did not report to me, it became quite evident that managing expectations of her work performance was an ongoing issue for her manager. She was eventually exited from the company.
Those experiences as well as many others have taught me you can not necessarily “teach” strong character.
Desirable Work Ethic Characteristics:
- Cooperation
- Dedication
- Discipline
- Integrity
- Productivity
- Professionalism
- Reliability
- Responsibility
A resume may not necessarily reveal an applicant’s character. Asking the right questions in an interview, and of references, might help to uncover their true nature. When evaluating an individual in a hiring situation, here is what I look for:
- A team player, with a respectful attitude, able to take direction.
- Focused on their work tasks, responds in a timely fashion, and complete their assignments with little error.
- Someone who exceeds expectations by seeking out opportunities to learn and improve.
- Conducts themselves in an honest and ethical manner.
- Someone who is reliable and takes pride in finishing their work on time.
Selecting the right person for the job should be more than just a gut feeling. A bad hire can be a costly mistake, and counterproductive to the existing team dynamic or company culture.

The hiring manager should be sure to share the company’s culture and clear about what is expected of an employee. This will give the potential hire a better understanding of the overall job requirements. Having the right resume does not automatically make an individual the right hire. Check both professional (work) and volunteer references. How someone performs in an unpaid volunteer role is indicator of an individual’s true work ethic. Someone who is reliable and passionate about their volunteer work and is respected by their fellow volunteers tells volumes about what it is like to work a person. Spending the time to thoroughly screen and evaluate candidates will pay off in the long run.